A quiet late-autumn pocket garden with a wooden bench, copper leaves and historic brick rowhouses in Pittsburgh.

A Walk Through the Mexican War Streets, One Street Name at a Time

This year, a grocery run in the Mexican War Streets stopped meaning a walk into the middle of the grid. Mayfly Market & Deli opened on Arch Street in 2018. In February it moved into the restored Garden Theater on West North Avenue, next door to a Czech lager bar that opened there this spring. Now the neighborhood's errands happen at its North Avenue edge. The streets inside the grid still carry their 1848 battle names, and they hold the coffee corner, the gardens, the art houses and a Christmas Eve tradition on Palo Alto Street. Here's what sits on each of those streets as of late November.

How the streets got their names

General William Robinson, a former mayor of Allegheny City, laid out the housing development in 1848. The Mexican-American War ran from 1846 to 1848, so Robinson was building streets while the news was still current. Michael Krauss, curator at Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall and Museum, told 90.5 WESA in 2022: "And what better tribute than to name it after what was going on right then?"

Monterey, Palo Alto and Resaca were all named for battles in that war. Buena Vista is a battle name too, and Resaca Place is short for the Battle of Resaca de la Palma. Not every name on the map is a battle. WESA notes that Taylor Avenue honors Zachary Taylor, the general who later became president, and Fremont Street is named for Captain John Fremont. Drovers Way is named for an early local trade. Brittany Urban of the Mexican War Streets Society told the station that "a drover is a person who drives cattle," and that many early residents were blacksmiths, tanners and merchants.

Those early families lived in modest houses. Through the late 1800s and early 1900s, as Allegheny City grew wealthier, many of those houses were enlarged to roughly the size they are today. Pittsburgh annexed Allegheny City in 1907. Allegheny residents fought the annexation all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, and they lost. The street signs are older than that annexation.

Buena Vista at Jacksonia

For coffee, the corner to know is Buena Vista and Jacksonia. Commonplace Coffee's café is at 1501 Buena Vista Street and is open every day from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. Its outdoor seating is across the street at Mechanics' Retreat, a garden that Mexican War Streets Society volunteers look after.

The garden looks different this year than it did a year ago. According to the Society's events page, trees there were removed in January. Volunteers came out on Tuesday, April 21, 2026, to plant replacements. In the growing season the group meets weekly to work on the beds.

Sampsonia Way and Monterey Street

Sampsonia Way is the alley where the neighborhood's buildings carry text. City of Asylum has turned five houses there into published works, with literary text worked into their facades: House Poem, Winged House, Pittsburgh-Burma House, Jazz House, and Comma House. Comma House was finished in 2021 and is the newest. City of Asylum also runs the Alphabet Reading Garden at 1406 Monterey Street. The Society's neighborhood guide describes its gate, which reads "Joy is an Act of Resistance."

The Mattress Factory has buildings on both streets. Its museum is at 509 Jacksonia Street, its galleries are at 500 and 516 Sampsonia Way and 1414 Monterey Street, and it keeps regular hours Wednesday through Sunday. The museum started 2026 under a new artistic director, Anthony Elms. The museum announced his hiring in December 2025, and his tenure began in February.

The newest show opened Saturday, Nov. 14. Greer Lankton: Could It Be Love is at 500 Sampsonia. It has 24 rarely seen photographs Lankton took of her own dolls, curated by Francis Schichtel and Jordan Weitzman. The show ties back to the museum itself, since Lankton showed her first full-scale installation at the Mattress Factory not long before her death in 1996. Ting Tong Chang's The Hidden Shift is also at 500 Sampsonia through March 14, 2027. On Monterey, the 1414 building has had Akea Brionne's exhibition since Oct. 17. It's presented with Pedantic Arts Residency and draws on Creole culture and the African Diaspora. So within one short walk, a back alley and a street named for a battle hold a group of literary facades and three contemporary art shows.

Arch Street, after Mayfly

Until this year, Arch Street was where you went for groceries. Mayfly Market sold grocery staples, gourmet deli goods, produce and baked goods at 1327 Arch, in the middle of the War Streets. In June 2025 the Northside Chronicle reported the plan to move. The new space would be about 3,000 square feet, nearly twice the 1,500-square-foot Arch Street shop, with more kitchen and refrigeration room for prepared foods, grab-and-go items, frozen goods, meats and vegetables. The move happened in February 2026. Mayfly's website now lists 30 W. North Ave., with produce, deli soups, salads and spreads, staples, baked goods, coffee, fresh bread, sorbet and flowers.

Arch Street still has its best-known landmark. Randyland at 1501 Arch began in 1995, when Randy Gilson bought a few run-down buildings and started turning them into the color-covered art site that now draws national and international visitors. Further up, the Olde Allegheny Community Gardens fill two city blocks of plots between Sherman and Arch Streets. Before February, a resident heading up Arch for a sandwich would pass all of these. Now that trip goes south toward North Avenue instead.

North Avenue, where the errands went

The Garden Theater block is where Mayfly ended up. Per Pittsburgh Magazine, the theater is a century-old Beaux-Arts cinema that closed in 2007. Attempts to revive it went on for two decades, and a partnership between Trek Development and Q Development finally reopened it. The Post-Gazette reported in October 2023 that the rehab covered the interior and exterior and restored the grand marquee. Q Development says the four-building project has 74 apartments. They're split among a new building at 6 W. North, the Bradberry with 16, the Morton House with 10, and three studios in the theater itself.

Mayfly's neighbor in the theater is The Bohemian, a taproom from Homestead's Golden Age Beer Co. at 22 W. North Ave. Pittsburgh Magazine reported it open as of April 27. It pours four Czech-style lagers, Pale, Gold, Pils and Dark, from side-pull Lukr faucets into hand-cleaned, slightly chilled glasses. They're brewed in Homestead, and you can only get them on tap here. The room has vinyl records, lounge seating and a 1970s look. Co-owner Pete Kurzweg, who lives in Deutschtown, told the magazine, "We found the space first and fell in love with it and the concept of bringing renewal to the North Side." The bar has grab-and-go food from Mayfly next door, and drinkers can also bring in food from Badamo's Pizza or El Burro across the street.

A few doors down at 40 W. North Ave., City of Asylum's Alphabet City has hosted readings, performances, a bookstore and a restaurant since it opened in fall 2016. The bookstore is open daily from noon to 6 p.m. Put together, one block of North Avenue now has the grocery, the beer, the bookstore and a dinner table. The battle-named streets behind it are mostly residential, apart from the coffee corner, the gardens and the art.

Palo Alto in December

The interior streets come back into use in December. The Mexican War Streets Society lists three December traditions: the members' holiday party at the Day House on North Avenue, a Holiday Decorating Contest with prizes, and luminaria along Palo Alto Street on Christmas Eve. This year's party is Sunday, Dec. 6, from 5 to 9 p.m. Guests are asked to bring a dish to share and a donation for the food pantry. Society membership is $20 a person, and the Society says it puts you on the list for "the best holiday party in the city."

A video posted on Christmas Day 2024 shows Palo Alto lit with luminaria on Christmas Eve and calls the tradition decades old. Palo Alto is one of the streets named for a battle, and on Christmas Eve it's the street lined with candles.

Thursday, the day this post goes up, is also the neighborhood's official stoop night in warm weather. The Society describes neighbors sitting out on their front steps, sometimes with a glass of wine, while others stop by to visit. It's too cold for that by late November. Stoop nights will be back when the weather warms. For more on how the rest of the North Side fills its calendar, see our posts on the North Side's October and the Northside Music Festival on East Ohio Street.

If you live on one of these streets and want to talk through how the new shops on North Avenue fit into your plans for your home, Black Key Partners is glad to have that conversation. Request a Concierge Consultation, and we'll start from the corner you know best.

Putting Your Goals First

When it comes to real estate, your success is more than just a goal – it’s my top priority. I am dedicated to providing the highest level of service, ensuring that every aspect of your real estate journey is aligned with your vision.

Follow Me on Instagram